top of page

Jeremy Bentham and the Panopticon: The prison that was never built

19 hours ago
3 min read

NATSIC-AS · Justice and corrections history

These historical models also prompt questions about whose experience counts when a custodial system is assessed.

Painted portrait of Jeremy Bentham beside an old drawing of his proposed circular prison.
Henry William Pickersgill, c.1829, UCL Art Museum; plan, 1843 printing of the 1791 design. Via Wikimedia Commons.

Imagine standing in a prison cell designed so that someone in a central lodge could see you, but you could not tell whether anyone was watching. The possibility of inspection was meant to do much of the work. That was the argument at the heart of Jeremy Bentham’s Panopticon. His English penitentiary was never built, but the proposal left a question that outlasted it: what happens when one side can watch without being seen?


The man behind the proposal

Jeremy Bentham (1748–1832) was an English thinker and law reformer. He studied at Oxford and trained in law, but became known for writing about how laws and institutions should be judged by their effects on people. His utilitarian approach asked whether a rule or practice increased well-being or caused avoidable harm. He applied that question to punishment, government, poor relief and much else. After his death, his remains were prepared under directions in his will; his preserved skeleton, dressed in his clothes and displayed with a wax head, forms the Auto-Icon at University College London. UCL Bentham Project: life and works.

Oil portrait of Jeremy Bentham, looking slightly to the left.
Henry William Pickersgill, portrait of Jeremy Bentham, exhibited 1829. UCL Art Museum PC5589, via Art UK and Wikimedia Commons. Public domain.

Samuel’s idea, Jeremy’s prison

The idea did not begin in an English jail. Jeremy’s younger brother Samuel developed the principle of central inspection while supervising workers in Russia. Jeremy adapted it into a proposal for an English penitentiary and argued that the principle could also be used in places such as schools, hospitals and workshops. The 1791 edition catalogued by the Wellcome Collection describes the letters as written in 1787. Bentham later refined the design in two postscripts. UCL Bentham Project: the Panopticon.

The drawings put cells around the perimeter and the inspection lodge in the centre. Light from the exterior made the cells visible from inside, while screens concealed the inspector from people in the cells. The scheme did not require an inspector to watch every person every minute. Bentham thought that if people could not tell when inspection was happening, they would act as if it might happen at any time. Read his reasoning in Letter V, “Essential Points of the Plan”.

Willey Reveley’s elevation and section of the proposed House of Inspection with an annotated central lodge.
Willey Reveley, elevation of the Houses of Inspection, c.1791, after Bentham’s design. Bentham Papers 119a/121. Public-domain drawing via Wikimedia Commons.

What the drawings cannot prove

Bentham presented the Panopticon as a system of management as well as a building. He argued that inspection could make supervision more economical and support the work and instruction of prisoners. But those were claims about how his model would operate, not results measured in a prison he ran. He spent years pursuing government backing without getting his proposed English prison built. UCL notes that prisons elsewhere incorporated some related features without reproducing the whole scheme. A circular plan or central viewpoint is not enough to establish that a prison was built to Bentham’s model. UCL on the proposal and its fate.

That distinction matters in Australia. The Separate Prison at Port Arthur is a useful comparison, not an Australian Panopticon. The site authority identifies London’s Pentonville Prison as its model. At Port Arthur, separation and silence were central to the regime; the layout and operating rules tell a different story from Bentham’s central inspection lodge. Port Arthur Historic Site Management Authority, Landscape Management Plan.


Watch: a reconstruction of the unbuilt design

Aeon Video presents Myles Zhang’s digital reconstruction of Bentham’s proposal. It is a modern model based on the drawings, not archival footage of a prison. Open on YouTube.


The question to ask today

A clear sightline can help staff spot an emergency or check on someone at risk. It does not tell them what happened before a camera clip started, what lies outside the frame or how a person experienced what was done. Those are different questions. The next time a prison design or monitoring system is sold as making everyone safer, ask what it will actually help staff see, what it cannot show and who can scrutinise the decisions made with it. A plan can show where an observer stands. It takes evidence to show whether the system works fairly.


Explore more history and corrections articles. Queensland prison officers can explore QPOA membership through MYUNION and check what membership covers before joining.

Comments


Commenting on this post isn't available anymore. Contact the site owner for more info.
bottom of page

Digital capability · Indigenous corporations

A website that works for your corporation.

Website development and practical website audits, starting with a free initial assessment and audit for Indigenous corporations.

Start with what you have

Tell us about your corporation, your public website and what you want it to achieve. The initial assessment helps identify priorities and the work worth doing next.

Agree the work before the price

After assessment, we agree the proposed scope, deliverables, price and timing with you before paid work begins. Website development and implementation are not included in the free initial audit.

Move forward at a practical pace

We aim for a fast turnaround, subject to the agreed scope, content, approvals and project requirements. Your expected delivery timeframe is agreed after assessment, not promised before we understand the work.

Supporting Indigenous business and future IT talent

Our aim is to help Indigenous corporations strengthen their online presence and create opportunities for young Indigenous workers to develop and excel in the growing IT sector. This is an intention for the service, not an announcement of current jobs, placements or a guaranteed employment outcome.

Hosting, information and control

Discuss your hosting and information-handling requirements during assessment. Australian service delivery does not by itself mean Australian-only data storage or processing. Website platforms and other technology providers may process information overseas. We do not promise that nothing leaves Australia.

For example, Wix explains its international processing and service providers. The appropriate platform and arrangements must be considered for each project.

Request your free initial assessment

Email gethelp@natsic.org with your corporation name, public website address (if you have one) and a brief description of your goals. Please do not send passwords, identity documents or confidential community information with an initial enquiry.